I'm a big fan of The Decemberists earlier albums. Colin has always had a knack for storytelling. Unfortunately, that is where this album falls short. The concept overshadows the music and ultimately the story is not engaging enough to carry the album. There are some highlights and low lights. The real story, however, is how much "Margaret in Captivity" rips off the 12 string guitar intro from Bon Jovi's "Wanted Dead or Alive." Listen to both songs then listen to this: http://www.filedropper.com/margaretwanteddeadoralive Uncanny, no?