This is why

[bjorn_skurj]

Obviously, we are working with an imperfect criminal justice system.

 

DNA clears man of 1981 rape conviction

 

By ANABELLE GARAY, Associated Press Writer1 hour, 31 minutes ago

 

A decorated Vietnam veteran convicted of rape 25 years ago became a free man Tuesday after a judge ruled he probably wouldn't have been found guilty if DNA testing had been available.

 

Specialized DNA testing performed this year proved Larry Fuller, 57, was not the assailant who raped a Dallas woman in her home. Fuller has spent about two decades in prison for the crime.

 

"My faith was tested and I won," he said, trembling slightly as he left the courthouse carrying two worn paperback Bibles.

 

Fuller was sentenced in 1981 to 50 years behind bars after jurors convicted him of aggravated rape. Authorities claimed that he broke into a 37-year-old woman's apartment and raped her, using a butcher knife to cut her as she struggled.

 

The woman looked at two photo lineups, both of which included Fuller. She picked him in the second one, even though Fuller was bearded in the picture and she said her attacker had no facial hair.

 

At the time, Fuller was a 32-year-old Vietnam veteran who had received the Air Medal for taking care of his crew. He was pursing a career in art and had worked as a driver and warehouse employee.

 

Fuller served 18 years in prison before being released in 1999. He was sent back to prison last year for a parole violation. All the while, he professed his innocence and tried to prove it through DNA. This year, the Dallas County prosecutor's office agreed to allow the additional testing.

 

Both the assistant district attorney and state District Judge Lana McDaniel apologized to Fuller; neither were involved in the original case. The judge said she felt sick to her stomach over all the time he spent in prison for a crime he didn't commit.

 

"Thank you," Fuller responded. "Apology accepted."

[deepseacatfish]

Exactly.

[Dreamin']

Reminds me of David Milgaard. Thank god for DNA testing!

[owl]

This is why I'm against the death penalty

 

Ditto

[jhc]

What about death penalty for cases where DNA evidence confirms guilt?

[tugmoose]

Question: Why in the F did it take them this long to get around to DNA testing in this case? Has this not been around for 10, 15, 20 years?

 

I said it before and I'll say it again: A comprehensive DNA data base would make catching criminals infinitely more easy and would quickly exonerate the wrongly accused. Or do you want rapists to claim 2 or 3 or 10 more victims before being caught?

[Dreamin']

What about death penalty for cases where DNA evidence confirms guilt?

I don't think the state should be allowed to take a human life. That's just not an acceptable punishment for any crime (IMO) and it's not a deterrent.

[jhc]

I don't think the state should be allowed to take a human life. That's just not an acceptable punishment for any crime (IMO) and it's not a deterrent.

 

Fair enough

[EL the Famous]

I don't think the state should be allowed to take a human life. That's just not an acceptable punishment for any crime (IMO) and it's not a deterrent.

 

I agree with you for the most part, but I also don't think that anyone should allowed to take human life outside of it being the only alternative to their own life being in jeapordy. What I mean is, i'd likely have a different opinion if someone were to take the life of one of my loved ones...i'd want retribution. Granted, life imprisonment w/ no chance of parole isn't anything to scoff at, but I don't know.