Cat Power & Neko Case Both Playing London...

[rghammo]

To me it seems more plausible that someone would have crippling stage freight than that someone would pretend to have crippling stage freight simply to increase show attendance/possibly album sales. I think this would hinge on the number of people who go to see her simply to see a trainwreck and I've never met anyone like that. Everyone I know says that they love her music but always hesitate to see her live because of the trainwreck possibility.

[Duck-Billed Catechist]

What's the point of that? I hardly know anything about this person, so I may be missing something.

Re: Ticket sales and that sort of thing, I don't think it's as calculated as all that. I've heard that she just really likes the attention.

 

 

Then there's this:

 

 

Exhausted, but exhilirated, in New Orleans

 

The 09/20/04 show in New Orleans was one of the most unique experiences of my life. I want to tell you about it. I was debating whether to make the hour-and-a-half drive alone, but I just knew when I saw a listing that Cat Power would be playing at The Parish in the House of Blues, I know there was no way I could let the opportunity pass me by, and I'm so glad I went.

 

The first glimpse I got of Chan was when she came into the audience to watch the opening act's last two numbers. She stood in front of me, and everyone immediately got embarassed and tried not to act like they were seeing an angel or a ghost roaming among men. No one who didn't know her personally already spoke to her. This is key to my impression of her and the show she put on.

 

She came on within 15 minutes of the close of the opening act. By the way, his last number singing "You can vote with a bullet" was priceless. The audience was entranced during the first 30 minutes, and she, as the reviewer in Dallas commented, instantly called for more reverb in the guitar and her voice after finishing most of the first song. After asking for more and more, she finally said that she was just going to wait until she got more reverb. She seemed frustrated, but not demanding - I don't want it to sound like that. Moreso disappointed, as if everything in the world is always cruel and meaningless, and she felt helpless. She said that she felt like she was going to barf, and seemed pretty uncomfortable in the dim limelight. A couple of more songs in, she also gave herself and the song a thumbs-down. The audience disagreed, fascinated with her, but she still hadn't felt satisfied with her performance so far. She whispered that a free t-shirt was available if someone wanted to light it on fire and throw it on-stage. She spoke quietly about her true misery at not being able to do what she really wanted to do well.

 

She referenced wanting to die several times, asking "How does that song go? I hate myself and I want to die," playing the intro to a Courtney Hole song "I'm Miss World, somebody kill me," later saying that she was waiting for the moment when someone would take a club to her head and beat it til she was dead, asking who was on anti-depressants and had ever tried to stop drinking. This all sounds extremely morbid, and it was, but never clawing or needy. It was exhilirating to hear someone who could so freely express herself without the stifling shame of saying the words that we in the audience all felt hearing them. I believe it's a beautiful gift to be able to express so freely without the fear that might stifle it.

 

In about the middle of the show, she asked the guy from the opening act (sorry I don't know his name) to play while she sang, and she walked out into the middle of the audience and sat down among the people to sing. Everyone craned their necks to get a look at her, and people even moved into spaces on the floor, relinquished by those who had long ago walked out, just to stare at her like she was a museum piece. I wished that I was sitting on the floor near her so that I could reach out to her so that I could embrace her -- hold her and be held by her. All that I could do was hang my head and listen as she sang/moaned out the lyrics while the speakers crackled every 5 or 10 seconds. She apologized so many times that I felt genuine agony for her. This one stupid guy sitting near her could only tenatively hold out a hand and pet her shoulder, as if this could comfort, as if anything could comfort. I have never seen an artist, or even a person, so unassumingly want to be part of the small community created in the moment around themselves, while simulataneously impossibly isolated and untouchable. What is it about our society that even those among us who consider ourselves deeply empathetic, wanting to reach out to others, have developed this chilly behavior for those who we truly want to connect with? Is it only ourselves that stop us? But, why?

 

As was written about the show in Dallas, at one point she seemed to lose all her momentum and any good cheer she had earlier, and started songs that she couldn't finish. Fans screamed out for a song they liked, one asshole yelled for a Nancy Sinatra song. Some just made fun of her, or went into the back of the club and talked loudly, interrupting her and the rest of us from the show. She tried to please by playing bits-and-pieces, but no longer had any stamina. She tuned her guitar and tried to find chords that she didn't know to cover someone else's songs. She went to the piano a couple of times, and smoked and drank out of a plastic cup more near the end of the show as if in desperation.

 

Overall, though, those that stuck around experienced an ultra-rare treat that I would pay triple for again.

 

I don't know. Does this sound like a very bad concert? To some, or maybe a lot, I guess it does. Maybe it's not what they want to be involved in. Maybe, like Chan seemed to believe at times and was disappointed in herself that she couldn't deliver, they think that a performance should follow a certain script where Moment A gives way to Moment B followed by Moment C and so on ending with Z. To me, the night I experienced was the cure to all of the other unbearable crap in this world that I wish would self-destruct. instead of Cat Power. Chan spoke of making a life change a few times during the night, and I was filled with a cold dread that she might stop making music or doing what she's been doing. I wish, for her sake alone, that she will find some peace and is able to release at least some of what hurts her. But I can't think of a more heavenly place than where I was last night, intimately involved in, feeling myself, that exhausting but exquisite pain.

 

 

 

 

and this:

http://www.drownedinsound.com/content/view/488279

The show - however powerful - is riddled with nervous forgetfulness and breakdowns half way through songs. Then there's the hushed apologizing, which is in a way sweet, but mildly worrying in that there's a blurring; when does the act end and fade into a reality? If it is there to give us a real desire to just shout something positive or run up and hug her, it's working; we are of course, all too shy. Her myth and majesty makes her seem like a bunsen-burner safety flame that you can run through your hand. Her almost ghost-like flickerings, put a tragic fear in the room whilst reminding us "I am your answer, I am living proof."

 

Maybe it is an act, maybe it isn't. Maybe she suffers from exposure and it really is this hard to live out a normal day before baring your soul to an audience - however receptive they may be. Regardless, the resulting performance is a muse unto those she touches, giving a hope and joy, or at the very least a my-life-ain't-this-bad looking glass for middle-class kids. The fact it all comes wrapped up in her timeless and perfect vocal delivery is what makes all of this special. It's the voice which will live on nevertheless. Based on tonight's show, she could/will become more than Tom Waits, Patti Smith or any of the true greats. When she speaks she's child-like, the only other I've seen so close to these shyly delicate mannerisms was cult-author JT Leroy.

[street spirit]

To me it seems more plausible that someone would have crippling stage freight than that someone would pretend to have crippling stage freight simply to increase show attendance/possibly album sales. I think this would hinge on the number of people who go to see her simply to see a trainwreck and I've never met anyone like that. Everyone I know says that they love her music but always hesitate to see her live because of the trainwreck possibility.

 

Yeah... it's not like the trainwrecks are even all that interesting. It's not like she pulls a tantrum and smashes up the joint or anything. It's usually just uncomfortable silence and walking off stage, which isn't even entertaining in that "oh look a car crash" way.

 

Neko will surely be a professional and tight sounding set, but honestly I've always found her a bit boring live. Yes she has an amazing voice, and yes she is very pretty, and yes her songs are quite good... but depending on who she's backed by, it's so close to the record live (shows with the Sadies, notwithstanding).

 

plus, Cat Power writes better songs.

 

If youre a gambling man, when Chan is on she's mesmerizing... that being said Neko/MWard is pretty much guaranteed to be good.

[pnêyu]

There's a story in the NY Times about Chan today: 9 Lives and Counting: Cat Power Sobers Up.

 

Rich, you'll do well whichever show you choose, but as everyone has noted, you have to leave all your expectations at the door of any Cat Power gig. Both women are mesmerizing in their own ways; it really comes down to your personal tastes.

[cusacker]

There's a story in the NY Times about Chan today: 9 Lives and Counting: Cat Power Sobers Up.

 

Rich, you'll do well whichever show you choose, but as everyone has noted, you have to leave all your expectations at the door of any Cat Power gig. Both women are mesmerizing in their own ways; it really comes down to your personal tastes.

well, i guess that article explains the reasoning behind the stage habits. i was aware that things were pretty bad at one point, but i had no idea they were that bad

glad to hear she is recovering and is gaining some confidence on stage...am really looking forward to this gig in november now!

[jimmyjimmy]

There's a story in the NY Times about Chan today: 9 Lives and Counting: Cat Power Sobers Up.

 

Thanks for that link...a terrifc article and video segment.