Jump to content

Adam2

Member
  • Content Count

    188
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Adam2

  1. yeah, i understand what you mean. it looks odd when you shelve a DVD of the whole band, a group performance, and instead release something that soloely focuses on you. i just don't get why he'd make a "documentary" of his solo tour... what's there to document, besides the concert? was it a particularly exciting driving to the next town? i don't get it.

  2. The Rhino reissues are fabulous. I'm not sure what fan wouldn't want them... the sound is better on both discs, great artwork, extended liner notes by Elvis... they are the way to go. The Bonus Discs are great... most people expect too much out of them. They are not there to top the original album or feature some miraculously "lost" track... they give a better picture of the time period/recording of the album and the process.

  3. I just put on dvd my brother-in-law gave me: German Hotel Kamera, and am watching 7/9/99, Rockpalast, Loreley, Germany, and am absolutely certain the current line-up rolls over Jay and company. I think by YHF Jay had given all he could and though integral to Wilco evolution, there's no comparison between line-ups now.

     

    My three cents.

     

    :cheers

     

     

    are you serious? the version of "Christ For President" from that show is the best I've ever heard... absolutely scorching. Listen to Leroy Bach's Hammond organ on "California Stars", "I Got You", etc. I agree that some aspects are done better by the current line up... but they're nowhere near as good as rocking the hell out of those songs.

  4. yes, the songs that have been played a few times live and have yet to be seen or heard on a studio release surely show that jeff is nothing without jay. And AGIB and the Loose Fur records never happened.

     

    I didn't say that at all, but whatever. The new songs don't sound that great to me, but if you think they're "the best music Jeff has made", good for you. You said Jay leaving freed up Jeff to create the some of the best music of his career. I'm saying that if those new songs are any indication, that's not true. Loose Fur's last record was fabulous... then again, Jim O'Rourke is in the band. I wish the new Wilco songs were as good as those.

  5. I think a lot of what he's saying is bullshit. Last time he played Chicago (Riviera in fall of 2004), he came on late and let the audience wait for like an hour and a half while he was getting a tatoo or some shit, then played until the 11:00 curfew. Then he says "oh, the venue has a curfew, so we had to get off". He probably played for like an hour or so.

  6. my impression was that he helped wilco's evolution on Being There just by being good at the guitar and keys, then he screwed up Summerteeth, and then he was going for a repeat on YHF but some weird dude named Jim fixed it.

     

    Jay is a talented guy, but he has a phony presence in his music that i find irritating. his absence freed up Jeff to create the best music of his career, or at least that's how i hear it.

     

    and has Jeff even tried producing?

     

     

    I think the "new" Wilco songs proves your theory wrong.

  7. i also agree that some of his stuff isn't as good as others. Bigger Than Blue is his best so far... the first half is great (including great songs like Charming and Plastic, Cajun Angel, Curiosity, Let's Count Our Losses, It's Hard). Its when he gets too carried away, like the second half of Blue, that its not very good. Beloved Enemy also has great songs, but again a few songs suffer from noisy experimentation.

×
×
  • Create New...