kida Posted January 31, 2006 Share Posted January 31, 2006 taken from the main forum: http://s61.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=2TOCP3B...S52LXD889DNEM89 just a place to start / basic chord patern would be awesome!! thanks Quote Link to post Share on other sites
kaysettes Posted January 31, 2006 Share Posted January 31, 2006 (edited) Does the song have a name? Edit: Nevermind, that was a stupid question. I'll work on it tonight. Edited January 31, 2006 by kaysettes Quote Link to post Share on other sites
danimal Posted February 5, 2006 Share Posted February 5, 2006 So I've been working on this song a bit. It's in open G, and the progression is all I - IV -V stuff (i.e. G-C-D). The basic lick is (my interpretation): (open G tuning -lots of hand-heel muting) G rhythym thing0-0-0-0h2-3-X --> 0-0-0-2p0-3-X C is:0-0-2-0-1-X D is:2-2-4-2-3-X for the verse, it's: [G] That's the thanks that I get [C] for loving you[G][G] That's the thanks that I get [C] for telling you the [G] truth[C] You say you wanna [D] know[G] Well I go and I go [C] General idea... please contribute, I'm still just working this out... the run up for (falsetto) 'I think we're both crazy' is pretty easy once you play the C-D part, too lazy to tab right now till I have it all figured out. Play the 'solo' along with him the figure the scale, it's G-minor pentatonic. Nice bluesy/soul feeling, he plays the muting in a funky way... practice that part (I still am!) A friend said this is her favorite Wilco/Tweedy song she's heard me play, and I still fuck it up here and there as I'm figuring it out. danimal Quote Link to post Share on other sites
jhc Posted February 6, 2006 Share Posted February 6, 2006 I just composed a long response with tab, and the @#$%# server puked on me and lost everything. I dont want to write it all again, but I just wanted to say I play this in the key of D using drop D tuning and it sounds pretty good to me (I'm using the Abbey recording as a guide) So I've been working on this song a bit. It's in open G, and the progression is all I - IV -V stuff (i.e. G-C-D). The basic lick is (my interpretation): (open G tuning -lots of hand-heel muting) G rhythym thing0-0-0-0h2-3-X --> 0-0-0-2p0-3-X C is:0-0-2-0-1-X D is:2-2-4-2-3-X for the verse, it's: [G] That's the thanks that I get [C] for loving you[G][G] That's the thanks that I get [C] for telling you the [G] truth[C] You say you wanna [D] know[G] Well I go and I go [C] General idea... please contribute, I'm still just working this out... the run up for (falsetto) 'I think we're both crazy' is pretty easy once you play the C-D part, too lazy to tab right now till I have it all figured out. Play the 'solo' along with him the figure the scale, it's G-minor pentatonic. Nice bluesy/soul feeling, he plays the muting in a funky way... practice that part (I still am!) A friend said this is her favorite Wilco/Tweedy song she's heard me play, and I still fuck it up here and there as I'm figuring it out. danimal Quote Link to post Share on other sites
danimal Posted February 7, 2006 Share Posted February 7, 2006 You know jhc, I agree and I think I ended up playing it in G more or less accidentally late at night. Dropped D for key of D (D - A - G for I - IV - V) sounds much more like the recording. I'm a little hectic to write a whole tab right now I wish you luck, I'm curious what you'll put up for the nice little run up, maybe I'll tab it out when I have more time. Danimal Quote Link to post Share on other sites
a.miller Posted February 7, 2006 Share Posted February 7, 2006 I just composed a long response with tab, and the @#$%# server puked on me and lost everything. I dont want to write it all again, but I just wanted to say I play this in the key of D using drop D tuning and it sounds pretty good to me (I'm using the Abbey recording as a guide)I agree. I just play it in Drop-D. I think the little riff Jeff does revolves around a d chord and using your pinky on the 4th string and walking it down 4-2-0. Jeff then barres the other chords with just the three lowest strings to get that muted sound, I belive. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
jhc Posted February 7, 2006 Share Posted February 7, 2006 OK, second try - this is still pretty rougg, and from memory so there will probably be an error or 10... D riff - I've been faking it, but I think some combination of what you have as "G rhythm thing" and abuharabi's riff is going to be the right one - [D] Is that the thanks that I get [G] for loving you[D][D] Is that the thanks that I get [G] for telling you the [D] truth[G] You say you wanna [A] know[G] Where I go when I go [A] (I think this is the correct lyric here)[G] You say you want to [A] communicate walk up: e------b-2-3-5-7-8--9--12-14g-0-0-0-0-0--0--0--0-d-2-4-5-7-9-11--12-14a-------d------- -------------But you don't hear a word I [G] say [D] Is that the thanks I [G] get for loving you [D] Well I'm tired of the looks I [G] get when I come [D] home late[D] And I'm getting tired of how you [G] forget the lovin' [D] things I say[G] I hold you [A] tight[G] Treat you [A] right[G] I don't [A] ever want to fight again (walk up)I think we're both crazy [G] [D] Is that the thanks I [G] get for loving you bridge part - I'm not too clear on this part at all Faith, trust, ???? lust... that's OK but you must belive in our [A] love...oohhh [D] We can make it better[G] We can make it better[D] We can make it better[G] Pull ourselves together and [D]start it again(Here I'm playing these as a blues shuff rhythm): ----D---------Ge-------------------b-------------------g-------------------d-0-0-0-----5-5-5a-0-2-0-----5-7-5d-0-0-0-----5-5-5 solo - ( I have an idea of what he's playing but it's not definitve) e----------------------------------b------3-5-3-0-------------------g-2s4----------------------------- then "D riff" - repeat whole thing onced----------------5-5--5-5--5-5---a----------------5-5--7-5--5-7---d----------------5-5--5-5--5-5--- [D] I hold you [G] tight[D] Tuck me in at [G] night[G] I don't [A] ever want to fight again (walk up)I think we're both crazy [G] [D] That's the thanks we [G] get for falling in [D] love [D] We can make it better[G] We can make it better[D] We can make it better[G] We can make it better[D] We can make it better[G] Pull ourselves together and [D]start it again Quote Link to post Share on other sites
kida Posted February 7, 2006 Author Share Posted February 7, 2006 awesome! thanks everyone Quote Link to post Share on other sites
jhc Posted February 9, 2006 Share Posted February 9, 2006 I hope one of you guys can fill in some of the blanks... that middle section is a big mental block for me Quote Link to post Share on other sites
a.miller Posted February 9, 2006 Share Posted February 9, 2006 excellent work jhc. I second the motion with the bluesy stuff on the chords. I'll add what I can add... Over the "you say you wanna know, where I go when I go" part, I (in drop D) swear I hear Jeff drop down lower the second and third time: (same for "hold you tight, treat you right" part, etc.)G(555xxx) A(777xxx) E(222xxx) (G)you say you wanna (A)know(E)where I go when I (G) go(E) you say you wanna communicate (G)...walk up(nice job on walk up jhc) "Faith, trust" part...I hear a B (999xxx) in there somewhere (but where...?) "we can make it better" melody (d(4th)--4-4--2-0-2-0) solo:D chord[xx0232] (on G string 2-h-4--2)A chord (--5-h-7--5-h-7--5)back to D chord (2--2-h-4--2)-->4 on D string-->same A progression (I think) I hope this helps and doesn't just add confusion..... P.S. I can only hope the rest of the forthcoming album is as awesome as I feel this song is. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.