Jump to content

Shakespeare In The Alley

Member
  • Content Count

    1,999
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Shakespeare In The Alley

  1.  

    I should have been more clear as to what I was referencing. The point is that this isnt YHF, it The Whole Love,and holding one album to the standard of another isn't right. If they wanted to remake YHF I believe they could. The line "The Whole Love isn't a Yankee Hotel Foxtrot freakout or mad gasp of creative freedom" completely misses the point of the album. It wasn't intended to be a YHF freakout. It is what it is. If critics, or fans for that matter, want to hold an artist or artists to their ideal past work it isn't a review, it is a comparative analysis. That is the point I believed the reviewer missed.

    Totally disagree here. I think the most logical comparison for a new Wilco album is past Wilco albums. That doesn't mean holding it to those past albums' standards, or that the comparisons will even have enough merit to begin with, but why wouldn't you compare TWL to what's come before it? Makes more sense than comparing it to non-Wilco material.

×
×
  • Create New...